Title capitalization guide
Is "Into" Capitalized in a Title?

No in AP and Chicago Style — "into" is lowercase in both. Yes in NYT Style.

preposition
Capitalized in 2 styles
Lowercase in 8 styles
Title Case
no
Lowercase as a short preposition unless first or last word
AP Style
no
Lowercase — AP lowercases all prepositions
NYT Style
YES
Capitalized — NYT Style capitalizes prepositions
Chicago Style
no
Lowercase — exactly four letters, at the threshold
MLA Style
no
Lowercase as a short preposition
APA Style
no
Sentence case — only first word and proper nouns
AMA Style
no
Lowercase — AMA follows AP-style preposition rules
BB Style
YES
Every word capitalized — no exceptions
Wikipedia Style
no
Sentence case — only first word and proper nouns
Sentence Case
no
Only the first word of a title is capitalized

The full answer

"Into" is a four-letter preposition that is lowercase in AP Style, Chicago Style, MLA Style, and AMA Style. NYT Style and Billboard Style capitalize it. Its treatment mirrors "with" and "from" exactly.

AP Style lowercases all prepositions, so "into" is consistently lowercase in journalism. The distinction between "into" and its five-letter counterparts like "about" does not exist under AP Style, since all prepositions are treated equally.

NYT Style capitalizes "into" as part of its convention of capitalizing prepositions. A title like "Falling Into the Deep" would appear as "Falling Into the Deep" in NYT Style but "Falling into the Deep" in AP Style.

"Into" as the first word of a title is always capitalized in every style guide. The first-word rule applies universally.

"Into" is a compound preposition formed from "in" and "to." It is four letters long, which places it exactly at Chicago Style's lowercase threshold alongside "with," "from," and "over."